Pilot Study for Essentiality Assessment of Standard Essential Patents

Rudi N.A. Bekkers, Joachim Henkel, Elena M. Tur, Tommy van der Vorst, Menno Driesse, Byeongwoo Kang, Arianna Martinelli, Wim Maas, Bram Nijhof, Emilio Raiteri, Lisa Teubner, Nikolaus Thumm (Editor)

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

230 Downloads (Pure)


This study investigates the technical and institutional feasibility of a system that ensures better essentiality scrutiny for Standard Essential Patents (SEPs).
We first studied the state of the art on essentiality assessment in literature, court cases involving larger scale essentiality assessments, essentiality assessment in patent pools, and the Japanese Hantei for Essentiality advisory opinion. A patent landscape analysis of SDO declared patents was performed to assess their use as input to essentiality assessment mechanisms. Technical feasibility was assessed in a pilot experiment, in whicha variety of assessors evaluated patents for their actual essentiality. Institutional feasibility was, among other means, assessed via a stakeholder workshop. Given (1) the observed interest in transparent data on essentiality of patents for standards, from implementers, patent owners and courts alike, (2) the potential benefits of such data for these parties and for the system as a whole, and (3) our finding that a system for generating such data seems both technically and institutionally feasible, we recommend policy makers to pursue the development and implementation of a system for essentiality assessments.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationLuxembourg
PublisherEuropean Union
Commissioning bodyEuropean Commission
Number of pages160
ISBN (Electronic)978-92-76-16667-2
ISBN (Print)978-92-76-16666-5
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2020
EventLaunch event for Pilot Study for Essentiality Assessment of Standard Essential Patents - Online, Brussels, Belgium
Duration: 2 Dec 20202 Dec 2020


Dive into the research topics of 'Pilot Study for Essentiality Assessment of Standard Essential Patents'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this