Human/robotic interaction: vision limits performance in simulated vitreoretinal surgery

Marc D. de Smet (Corresponding author), Nicky de Jonge, Danilo Iannetta, Koorosh Faridpooya, Eric van Oosterhout, Gerrit Naus, Thijs C.M. Meenink, Marco Mura, Maarten J. Beelen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Purpose: Compare accuracy and precision in XYZ of stationary and dynamic tasks performed by surgeons with and without the use of a tele-operated robotic micromanipulator in a simulated vitreoretinal environment. The tasks were performed using a surgical microscope or while observing a video monitor. Method: Two experienced and two novice surgeons performed tracking and static tasks at a fixed depth with hand-held instruments on a Preceyes Surgical System R0.4. Visualization was through a standard microscope or a video display. The distances between the instrument tip and the targets (in μm) determined tracking errors in accuracy and precision. Results: Using a microscope, dynamic or static accuracy and precision in XY (planar) movements were similar among test subjects. In Z (depth) movements, experience lead to more precision in both dynamic and static tasks (dynamic 35 ± 14 versus 60 ± 37 μm; static 27 ± 8 versus 36 ± 10 μm), and more accuracy in dynamic tasks (58 ± 35 versus 109 ± 79 μm). Robotic assistance improved both precision and accuracy in Z (1–3 ± 1 μm) in both groups. Using a video screen in combination with robotic assistance improved all performance measurements and reduced any differences due to experience. Conclusions: Robotics increases precision and accuracy, with greater benefit observed in less experienced surgeons. However, human control was a limiting factor in the achieved improvement. A major limitation was visualization of the target surface, in particular in depth. To maximize the benefit of robotic assistance, visualization must be optimized.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)672-678
Number of pages7
JournalActa Ophthalmologica
Volume97
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2019

    Fingerprint

Keywords

  • accuracy
  • depth perception
  • precision
  • robotics
  • simulation
  • telemanipulation
  • vitreoretinal surgery
  • Clinical Competence
  • Reproducibility of Results
  • Humans
  • Robotics/education
  • Education, Medical, Graduate/methods
  • Telemedicine/methods
  • Retinal Diseases/surgery
  • Video Recording
  • Vitreoretinal Surgery/education
  • Ophthalmology/education

Cite this