Experimental setup for objective evaluation of uterine motion analysis by ultrasound speckle tracking

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent research indicates uterine contractions to play an important role for the success of conception. Unfortunately, the lack of tools for quantitative analysis limits our understanding of the uterine contractility outside pregnancy. More recently, several ultrasound methods based on speckle tracking have gained attention for assessment of the uterine contractility; however, the absence of a ground truth hampers the optimization of the proposed tracking methods. To overcome this limitation, here we present an experimental setup based on a human ex-vivo uterus that generates controlled uterine motion for assessing the accuracy of motion tracking methods. Uterine motion was obtained by driving an electromagnetic actuator that produces controlled, sinusoidal displacement of a syringe piston connected to a balloon catheter filled with saline and inserted into the uterine cavity. This way, controlled uterine motion was generated while maintaining the original speckle characteristics. For validation, six needle markers were inserted in three ex-vivo uteri and tracked over time by optical flow. The motion of these markers was then compared with the driving signal of the electromagnetic actuator to assess the reproducibility of the produced uterine motion. Correlation coefficient (r), mean square error (MSE), and Hausdorff distance (H d) were the adopted objective metrics to evaluate the agreement between the signals. A use case is also presented where the proposed setup was tested to evaluate the speckle-tracking performance of block-matching by sum of absolute differences (SAD) with different block sizes. SAD with block size = 1.724 × 1.724 mm2 showed the highest agreement with the reference motion of the needle markers. To conclude, the proposed experimental setup generates controlled, rhythmic and reproducible uterine tissue motion representing a reliable ground truth for objective evaluation of speckle-tracking methods aimed at quantitative analysis of uterine motion outside pregnancy.

LanguageEnglish
Article number035012
Number of pages9
JournalBiomedical Physics & Engineering Express
Volume4
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - 13 Mar 2018

Fingerprint

Electromagnetic Phenomena
Uterus
Needles
Uterine Contraction
Pregnancy
Syringes
Catheters
Research

Keywords

  • block matching
  • experimental setup
  • motion analysis
  • speckle tracking
  • uterine motion
  • uterus

Cite this

@article{84b666a789044394ae81133549f8d906,
title = "Experimental setup for objective evaluation of uterine motion analysis by ultrasound speckle tracking",
abstract = "Recent research indicates uterine contractions to play an important role for the success of conception. Unfortunately, the lack of tools for quantitative analysis limits our understanding of the uterine contractility outside pregnancy. More recently, several ultrasound methods based on speckle tracking have gained attention for assessment of the uterine contractility; however, the absence of a ground truth hampers the optimization of the proposed tracking methods. To overcome this limitation, here we present an experimental setup based on a human ex-vivo uterus that generates controlled uterine motion for assessing the accuracy of motion tracking methods. Uterine motion was obtained by driving an electromagnetic actuator that produces controlled, sinusoidal displacement of a syringe piston connected to a balloon catheter filled with saline and inserted into the uterine cavity. This way, controlled uterine motion was generated while maintaining the original speckle characteristics. For validation, six needle markers were inserted in three ex-vivo uteri and tracked over time by optical flow. The motion of these markers was then compared with the driving signal of the electromagnetic actuator to assess the reproducibility of the produced uterine motion. Correlation coefficient (r), mean square error (MSE), and Hausdorff distance (H d) were the adopted objective metrics to evaluate the agreement between the signals. A use case is also presented where the proposed setup was tested to evaluate the speckle-tracking performance of block-matching by sum of absolute differences (SAD) with different block sizes. SAD with block size = 1.724 × 1.724 mm2 showed the highest agreement with the reference motion of the needle markers. To conclude, the proposed experimental setup generates controlled, rhythmic and reproducible uterine tissue motion representing a reliable ground truth for objective evaluation of speckle-tracking methods aimed at quantitative analysis of uterine motion outside pregnancy.",
keywords = "block matching, experimental setup, motion analysis, speckle tracking, uterine motion, uterus",
author = "F. Sammali and C. Blank and L. Xu and Y. Huang and N.P.M. Kuijsters and B.C. Schoot",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "13",
doi = "10.1088/2057-1976/aab053",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
journal = "Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express",
issn = "2057-1976",
publisher = "Institute of Physics",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Experimental setup for objective evaluation of uterine motion analysis by ultrasound speckle tracking

AU - Sammali,F.

AU - Blank,C.

AU - Xu,L.

AU - Huang,Y.

AU - Kuijsters,N.P.M.

AU - Schoot,B.C.

PY - 2018/3/13

Y1 - 2018/3/13

N2 - Recent research indicates uterine contractions to play an important role for the success of conception. Unfortunately, the lack of tools for quantitative analysis limits our understanding of the uterine contractility outside pregnancy. More recently, several ultrasound methods based on speckle tracking have gained attention for assessment of the uterine contractility; however, the absence of a ground truth hampers the optimization of the proposed tracking methods. To overcome this limitation, here we present an experimental setup based on a human ex-vivo uterus that generates controlled uterine motion for assessing the accuracy of motion tracking methods. Uterine motion was obtained by driving an electromagnetic actuator that produces controlled, sinusoidal displacement of a syringe piston connected to a balloon catheter filled with saline and inserted into the uterine cavity. This way, controlled uterine motion was generated while maintaining the original speckle characteristics. For validation, six needle markers were inserted in three ex-vivo uteri and tracked over time by optical flow. The motion of these markers was then compared with the driving signal of the electromagnetic actuator to assess the reproducibility of the produced uterine motion. Correlation coefficient (r), mean square error (MSE), and Hausdorff distance (H d) were the adopted objective metrics to evaluate the agreement between the signals. A use case is also presented where the proposed setup was tested to evaluate the speckle-tracking performance of block-matching by sum of absolute differences (SAD) with different block sizes. SAD with block size = 1.724 × 1.724 mm2 showed the highest agreement with the reference motion of the needle markers. To conclude, the proposed experimental setup generates controlled, rhythmic and reproducible uterine tissue motion representing a reliable ground truth for objective evaluation of speckle-tracking methods aimed at quantitative analysis of uterine motion outside pregnancy.

AB - Recent research indicates uterine contractions to play an important role for the success of conception. Unfortunately, the lack of tools for quantitative analysis limits our understanding of the uterine contractility outside pregnancy. More recently, several ultrasound methods based on speckle tracking have gained attention for assessment of the uterine contractility; however, the absence of a ground truth hampers the optimization of the proposed tracking methods. To overcome this limitation, here we present an experimental setup based on a human ex-vivo uterus that generates controlled uterine motion for assessing the accuracy of motion tracking methods. Uterine motion was obtained by driving an electromagnetic actuator that produces controlled, sinusoidal displacement of a syringe piston connected to a balloon catheter filled with saline and inserted into the uterine cavity. This way, controlled uterine motion was generated while maintaining the original speckle characteristics. For validation, six needle markers were inserted in three ex-vivo uteri and tracked over time by optical flow. The motion of these markers was then compared with the driving signal of the electromagnetic actuator to assess the reproducibility of the produced uterine motion. Correlation coefficient (r), mean square error (MSE), and Hausdorff distance (H d) were the adopted objective metrics to evaluate the agreement between the signals. A use case is also presented where the proposed setup was tested to evaluate the speckle-tracking performance of block-matching by sum of absolute differences (SAD) with different block sizes. SAD with block size = 1.724 × 1.724 mm2 showed the highest agreement with the reference motion of the needle markers. To conclude, the proposed experimental setup generates controlled, rhythmic and reproducible uterine tissue motion representing a reliable ground truth for objective evaluation of speckle-tracking methods aimed at quantitative analysis of uterine motion outside pregnancy.

KW - block matching

KW - experimental setup

KW - motion analysis

KW - speckle tracking

KW - uterine motion

KW - uterus

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047263811&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/2057-1976/aab053

DO - 10.1088/2057-1976/aab053

M3 - Article

VL - 4

JO - Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express

T2 - Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express

JF - Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express

SN - 2057-1976

IS - 3

M1 - 035012

ER -