E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures

C. Asensio, I. Pavón, R. Pagan Munoz

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademic

1 Citation (Scopus)
33 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The increasing importance of pollutant noise has led to the creation of many new noise testing laboratories in recent years. For this reason and due to the legal implications that noise reporting may have, it is necessary to create procedures intended to guarantee the quality of the testing and its results. For instance, the ISO/IEC standard 17025:2005 specifies general requirements for the competence of testing laboratories. In this standard, interlaboratory comparisons are one of the main measures that must be applied to guarantee the quality of laboratories when applying specific methodologies for testing. In the specific case of environmental noise, round robin tests are usually difficult to design, as it is difficult to find scenarios that can be available and controlled while the participants carry out the measurements. Monitoring and controlling the factors that can influence the measurements (source emissions, propagation, background noise...) is not usually affordable, so the most extended solution is to create very effortless scenarios, where most of the factors that can have an influence on the results are excluded (sampling, processing of results, background noise, source detection...) The new approach described in this paper only requires the organizer to make actual measurements (or prepare virtual ones). Applying and interpreting a common reference document (standard, regulation...), the participants must analyze these input data independently to provide the results, which will be compared among the participants. The measurement costs are severely reduced for the participants, there is no need to monitor the scenario conditions, and almost any relevant factor can be included in this methodology.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;
EditorsM. Crocker
Place of PublicationRio de Janeiro, Brazil
PublisherInternational Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV)
Pages758-764
Volume1
ISBN (Electronic)9781618392596
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2011
Event18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration (ICSV 18), July 10-14, 2011, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil - Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Duration: 10 Jul 201114 Jul 2011
http://www.lavi.coppe.ufrj.br/icsv18/

Conference

Conference18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration (ICSV 18), July 10-14, 2011, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Abbreviated titleICSV 18
CountryBrazil
CityRio de Janeiro
Period10/07/1114/07/11
OtherICSV18
Internet address

Fingerprint

background noise
methodology
contaminants
sampling
costs
requirements
propagation

Keywords

  • Background noise
  • Environmental noise
  • Input data
  • Interlaboratory comparison
  • ISO/IEC standard
  • Legal implications
  • Measurement costs
  • Monitoring and controlling
  • Noise testing
  • Round Robin test
  • Source detection
  • Testing laboratories
  • Transport infrastructure

Cite this

Asensio, C., Pavón, I., & Pagan Munoz, R. (2011). E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures. In M. Crocker (Ed.), 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil; (Vol. 1, pp. 758-764). Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV).
Asensio, C. ; Pavón, I. ; Pagan Munoz, R. / E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures. 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;. editor / M. Crocker. Vol. 1 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil : International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV), 2011. pp. 758-764
@inproceedings{90411e88a17044fd8263a73a95e987da,
title = "E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures",
abstract = "The increasing importance of pollutant noise has led to the creation of many new noise testing laboratories in recent years. For this reason and due to the legal implications that noise reporting may have, it is necessary to create procedures intended to guarantee the quality of the testing and its results. For instance, the ISO/IEC standard 17025:2005 specifies general requirements for the competence of testing laboratories. In this standard, interlaboratory comparisons are one of the main measures that must be applied to guarantee the quality of laboratories when applying specific methodologies for testing. In the specific case of environmental noise, round robin tests are usually difficult to design, as it is difficult to find scenarios that can be available and controlled while the participants carry out the measurements. Monitoring and controlling the factors that can influence the measurements (source emissions, propagation, background noise...) is not usually affordable, so the most extended solution is to create very effortless scenarios, where most of the factors that can have an influence on the results are excluded (sampling, processing of results, background noise, source detection...) The new approach described in this paper only requires the organizer to make actual measurements (or prepare virtual ones). Applying and interpreting a common reference document (standard, regulation...), the participants must analyze these input data independently to provide the results, which will be compared among the participants. The measurement costs are severely reduced for the participants, there is no need to monitor the scenario conditions, and almost any relevant factor can be included in this methodology.",
keywords = "Background noise, Environmental noise, Input data, Interlaboratory comparison, ISO/IEC standard, Legal implications, Measurement costs, Monitoring and controlling, Noise testing, Round Robin test, Source detection, Testing laboratories, Transport infrastructure",
author = "C. Asensio and I. Pav{\'o}n and {Pagan Munoz}, R.",
year = "2011",
month = "7",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "758--764",
editor = "M. Crocker",
booktitle = "18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;",
publisher = "International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV)",

}

Asensio, C, Pavón, I & Pagan Munoz, R 2011, E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures. in M Crocker (ed.), 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;. vol. 1, International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, pp. 758-764, 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration (ICSV 18), July 10-14, 2011, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 10/07/11.

E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures. / Asensio, C.; Pavón, I.; Pagan Munoz, R.

18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;. ed. / M. Crocker. Vol. 1 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil : International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV), 2011. p. 758-764.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademic

TY - GEN

T1 - E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures

AU - Asensio, C.

AU - Pavón, I.

AU - Pagan Munoz, R.

PY - 2011/7

Y1 - 2011/7

N2 - The increasing importance of pollutant noise has led to the creation of many new noise testing laboratories in recent years. For this reason and due to the legal implications that noise reporting may have, it is necessary to create procedures intended to guarantee the quality of the testing and its results. For instance, the ISO/IEC standard 17025:2005 specifies general requirements for the competence of testing laboratories. In this standard, interlaboratory comparisons are one of the main measures that must be applied to guarantee the quality of laboratories when applying specific methodologies for testing. In the specific case of environmental noise, round robin tests are usually difficult to design, as it is difficult to find scenarios that can be available and controlled while the participants carry out the measurements. Monitoring and controlling the factors that can influence the measurements (source emissions, propagation, background noise...) is not usually affordable, so the most extended solution is to create very effortless scenarios, where most of the factors that can have an influence on the results are excluded (sampling, processing of results, background noise, source detection...) The new approach described in this paper only requires the organizer to make actual measurements (or prepare virtual ones). Applying and interpreting a common reference document (standard, regulation...), the participants must analyze these input data independently to provide the results, which will be compared among the participants. The measurement costs are severely reduced for the participants, there is no need to monitor the scenario conditions, and almost any relevant factor can be included in this methodology.

AB - The increasing importance of pollutant noise has led to the creation of many new noise testing laboratories in recent years. For this reason and due to the legal implications that noise reporting may have, it is necessary to create procedures intended to guarantee the quality of the testing and its results. For instance, the ISO/IEC standard 17025:2005 specifies general requirements for the competence of testing laboratories. In this standard, interlaboratory comparisons are one of the main measures that must be applied to guarantee the quality of laboratories when applying specific methodologies for testing. In the specific case of environmental noise, round robin tests are usually difficult to design, as it is difficult to find scenarios that can be available and controlled while the participants carry out the measurements. Monitoring and controlling the factors that can influence the measurements (source emissions, propagation, background noise...) is not usually affordable, so the most extended solution is to create very effortless scenarios, where most of the factors that can have an influence on the results are excluded (sampling, processing of results, background noise, source detection...) The new approach described in this paper only requires the organizer to make actual measurements (or prepare virtual ones). Applying and interpreting a common reference document (standard, regulation...), the participants must analyze these input data independently to provide the results, which will be compared among the participants. The measurement costs are severely reduced for the participants, there is no need to monitor the scenario conditions, and almost any relevant factor can be included in this methodology.

KW - Background noise

KW - Environmental noise

KW - Input data

KW - Interlaboratory comparison

KW - ISO/IEC standard

KW - Legal implications

KW - Measurement costs

KW - Monitoring and controlling

KW - Noise testing

KW - Round Robin test

KW - Source detection

KW - Testing laboratories

KW - Transport infrastructure

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0-84871517854&partnerID=40&md5=f5ef1f8f70a1c1d197ab02100059574b

M3 - Conference contribution

VL - 1

SP - 758

EP - 764

BT - 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;

A2 - Crocker, M.

PB - International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV)

CY - Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

ER -

Asensio C, Pavón I, Pagan Munoz R. E-comparisons: A new approach to round robin tests for environmental noise assessment in transport infrastructures. In Crocker M, editor, 18th International Congress on Sound and Vibration 2011, ICSV 2011; Rio de Janeiro; Brazil;. Vol. 1. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: International Institute of Acoustics and Vibration (IIAV). 2011. p. 758-764