TY - JOUR
T1 - Comments on "A shaped reflector antenna for 60-GHz indoor wireless LAN access points"
AU - Smulders, P.F.M.
AU - Khusial, S.
AU - Herben, M.H.A.J.
PY - 2002
Y1 - 2002
N2 - The author comments that the shaped reflector antenna principles and theory of Smulders, Khusial and Herben (see ibid., vol.50, p.584-91, Mar.2001) are based on the papers described by Kumar (see Proc. Montech '86 IEEE Conference on Antennas and Communication, 1986, IEEE Cat. No. TH0156-0, Inst. Elect. Eng. Proc., vol.134, p.106-108, 1987 and Technology Symposium, 1990). These papers described the X-band, circularly polarized shaped beam telemetry antenna suitable for retransmitting the radar data back to an earth terminal. Smulders et al. have used the same principle, and similar types of radiation patterns are produced. However, two points are different in their paper: (1) the design frequency (60 GHz) and (2) the application of antenna for indoor wireless LAN access points. Therefore, they authors should have referenced Kumar's papers. Smulders et al. agree with Kumar's comments that reflector shaping is nothing new. However, we took into account diffraction effects (by applying the uniform theory of diffraction) whereas the shaping in the paper of Kumar is based on geometrical optics, only. We showed that according to our approach, a more smooth illumination function can be achieved and how the smoothing effect depends on the amount of edge illumination. We also showed in which way the spatial field deviation can be minimized and that this could save a few decibels in the link budget.
AB - The author comments that the shaped reflector antenna principles and theory of Smulders, Khusial and Herben (see ibid., vol.50, p.584-91, Mar.2001) are based on the papers described by Kumar (see Proc. Montech '86 IEEE Conference on Antennas and Communication, 1986, IEEE Cat. No. TH0156-0, Inst. Elect. Eng. Proc., vol.134, p.106-108, 1987 and Technology Symposium, 1990). These papers described the X-band, circularly polarized shaped beam telemetry antenna suitable for retransmitting the radar data back to an earth terminal. Smulders et al. have used the same principle, and similar types of radiation patterns are produced. However, two points are different in their paper: (1) the design frequency (60 GHz) and (2) the application of antenna for indoor wireless LAN access points. Therefore, they authors should have referenced Kumar's papers. Smulders et al. agree with Kumar's comments that reflector shaping is nothing new. However, we took into account diffraction effects (by applying the uniform theory of diffraction) whereas the shaping in the paper of Kumar is based on geometrical optics, only. We showed that according to our approach, a more smooth illumination function can be achieved and how the smoothing effect depends on the amount of edge illumination. We also showed in which way the spatial field deviation can be minimized and that this could save a few decibels in the link budget.
U2 - 10.1109/TVT.2002.807482
DO - 10.1109/TVT.2002.807482
M3 - Article
SN - 0018-9545
VL - 51
SP - 1681
EP - 1681
JO - IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
JF - IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology
IS - 6
ER -